Detroitnewsarticle050505
Get the latest Autos Insider reports

Click here for 2005 Spring Perennial Exchange

Get the latest Autos Insider reports Latest Autos Insider reports    
Search detnews.com

Previous Story     Next Story    

Thursday, May 5, 2005

Image
Brandy Baker / The Detroit News

GM retiree James Bergstrom watched with alarm as GM's U.S. market share has slid to near an all-time low in recent months.

Stock buy met with pessimism, optimism

Some say Kerkorian is out to make a buck; others say automaker needs the assistance.

Image
Robin Buckson / The Detroit News

Brian Tellier, general sales manager at Jefferson Chevrolet in Detroit, believes much of the reaction to Kerkorian's action is exaggerated.

Kerkorian and GM

Do you think Kirk Kerkorian's move to acquire 9% of General Motors' stock will turn out to be good or bad for GM?

Good
Bad
No effect

Get results and comments

Comment on this story
Send this story to a friend
Get Home Delivery

When Sam Jarbou heard that the price of General Motors Corp. stock was on the rise after billionaire investor Kirk Kerkorian made an offer Wednesday to more than double his stake in the company, the 50-year-old gas station owner made a beeline for his broker's office in Troy and cashed out his 4,000 shares.

Jarbou, who a month ago bought GM stock at $27.50 per share, cleared a handsome $12,000 profit when he sold at $30.50. But he also believes the embattled automaker benefited from Kerkorian's move by getting a much-needed vote of confidence from the seasoned investor.

"It's good for GM," he said, "and it's good for me."

Not everyone with ties to the world's largest automaker shared Jarbou's optimism on Wednesday, as reports that Kerkorian was setting his sights on GM rippled through Metro Detroit and around the world.

Some former workers fear that Kerkorian is only out to make a buck and does not have the company's best interests at heart, while some investors struggled to believe Kerkorian's claim that his play for a bigger chunk of GM was only for investment purposes.

Yet, there was consensus on one thing: that Kerkorian's bid to acquire an additional almost 5 percent of GM -- up from his roughly 4 percent stake today -- seemed to signal the start of something bigger.

James Bergstrom, a GM retiree from Flint, watched with alarm as GM's U.S. market share slid to near an all-time low in recent months and the automaker posted a $1.1 billion loss in the first quarter.

"I don't know which way (Kerkorian) would go, but any change would be good," said Bergstrom, 61, standing in front of GM World Headquarters at the Renaissance Center in downtown Detroit. "This company needs help."

But some workers would rather see that assistance come from another source.

Tom Simpson, 58, a former hourly worker at GM's parts division in Pontiac, believes Kerkorian is taking advantage of GM's vulnerable position and has no intention of helping to turn the company around.

"It's kind of like a vulture that sees a weakened body on the ground and swoops down to eat it," said Simpson, who now lives in Clearwater, Fla.

GM retiree Jack Dickinson echoes that thought. "I don't believe this gentleman has the best interests of this company and its employees at heart," said Dickinson, who maintains www.overthehillcarpeople.com, a Web site for GM employees and retirees.

For investors who hold a large interest in GM, however, Kerkorian's move to increase his stake brought a welcome boost in the company's stock price, which has been headed downward for months.

In trading on Wednesday, GM's stock rose 18 percent -- its biggest gain in nearly 50 years -- to close at $32.80 per share on the New York Stock Exchange.

"Clearly, we're happy investors today," said David Giroux, analyst with T Rowe Price, an investment firm in Baltimore, Md., that holds 1.3 million GM shares. But Giroux believes the stock is still undervalued and could be lifted higher as more eyes turn toward GM.

In the near term, Kerkorian's move could put pressure on the United Auto Workers union to make concessions on health care costs and other expenses to help GM become more competitive and better able to fend off takeover plays by outside investors, Giroux said. The UAW is likely to prefer dealing with a known entity like GM, rather than an unpredictable investor like Kerkorian, he said.

The UAW declined to comment on Kerkorian's bid to acquire a bigger stake in GM.

Other large GM investors seemed unfazed by news of Kerkorian's offer, viewing it more as a technical movement of the market than a symbolic shift in ownership at one of the country's largest companies.

"We're a long-term investor," said Sherry Reser, spokeswoman for the California State Teachers' Retirement System in Sacramento, one of the largest institutional investors in GM with about 1.8 million shares. "So we don't react to the day-to-day movements of the market."

Though Kerkorian's stake in GM is poised to increase, the deal may not have much impact on employees and dealers.

Brian Tellier, general sales manager at Jefferson Chevrolet in Detroit, believes much of the reaction to Kerkorian's action is exaggerated.

"Nine percent is still a long, long way from a controlling interest," he said.

And it is still unclear to many what Kerkorian will do with his stake in GM.

Jarbou, the investor who sold his GM shares on Wednesday, believes the interest from a seasoned investor like Kerkorian could only strengthen the ailing company's position. But he is confident the automaker will find its way out of trouble -- with or without Kerkorian.

"GM will be back, you watch," he said. "I never worry about GM. They always come back."

You can reach Brett Clanton at (313) 222-2612 or bclanton@detnews.com.


Image
Robin Buckson / The Detroit News

Sam Jarbou, a GM investor, believes interest from Kirk Kerkorian can only strengthen General Motors.

Previous Story     Next Story    


 Autos Insider 

  • Autos Insider index for Thursday, May 5, 2005
  • Kerkorian targets GM
  • Billionaire sees potential in ailing carmaker
  • Stock buy met with pessimism, optimism
  • Kerkorian's bold GM play may spark industry shake-up
  • Supplier details its global cuts
  • Kerkorian seeks 9% stake in GM
  • Weak truck sales hurt GM and Ford
  • ArvinMeritor to downsize
  • Ford fights Internet posting of roof-safety documents
  • Weak dollar squeezes BMW
  • Magna earnings off 3.9% from cutbacks
  • GM, Ford report lower April sales, while Asians gain ground
  • Mercedes-Benz: Alabama plant shows global strategy right
  • GM to hire 900 at Orion plant
  • Agency checks brake sensors on 1.3 million GM trucks
  • DuPont lays off 50 in Troy
  • Federal-Mogul scraps finance plan
  • Volvo is facing pressure over faulty throttles
  • Outside-the-box Scion scores with young drivers
  • Automakers put more women at the wheel
  • As fill-up price nears $100, big SUV sales fall
  • BMW keeps outlook despite sagging 1st-quarter profits
  • Delphi and Bosal sign exhaust deal


  • Copyright © 2005
    The Detroit News.
    Use of this site indicates your agreement to the Terms of Service (updated 12/19/2002).

     

    Top Of Page